Media
- Home
- Details
The South-South Zone of the Tax Appeal Tribunal, sitting in Benin City, Edo State, has struck out a preliminary objection filed by the Edo State Internal Revenue Service challenging the competence of an appeal instituted by Divine Wisdom Institute and Pastor Edwin over a Tax Bill Notice of Assessment issued by the Service.
The Tribunal held that a taxpayer aggrieved by a tax assessment has the right to choose from the available options for challenging the assessment, including approaching the Tribunal directly without first filing an objection with the relevant tax authority.
In its ruling, the Panel, presided over by Hon. Anselm Ungwugwaye Unimna, held that a Notice of Refusal to Amend (NORA) is not a mandatory precondition for instituting proceedings before the Tax Appeal Tribunal.
The dispute arose following a Tax Bill Notice of Assessment dated February 2026, issued to Divine Wisdom Institute and Pastor Edwin by the Edo State Internal Revenue Service. Dissatisfied with the assessment, the appellants instituted an appeal before the Tribunal in April 2026.
However, the Edo State Internal Revenue Service subsequently filed a preliminary objection challenging the competence of the appeal. The Service argued that the appellants had failed to comply with the Nigeria Tax Administration Act, 2025, which provides for the filing of an objection with the relevant tax authority by a taxable person disputing an assessment.
The Revenue Service maintained that the appellants were required to exhaust the internal objection process before approaching the Tribunal and consequently urged the Panel to strike out the appeal for being premature and incompetent.
In opposition, Divine Wisdom Institute and Pastor Edwin argued that the Tax Appeal Tribunal (Procedure) Rules, 2021, permit a person aggrieved by or dissatisfied with a tax assessment to approach the Tribunal directly without first submitting an objection to the relevant tax authority.
They further contended that their right of appeal was not conditional upon exhausting the internal dispute resolution mechanism provided under the Nigeria Tax Administration Act, 2025.
In response, the Edo State Internal Revenue Service argued that Order III Rule 1 of the 2021 Rules was inconsistent with Section 145 of the Nigeria Tax Administration Act, 2025, which gives the Act precedence over other laws relating to the administration, assessment, collection and enforcement of taxes and levies.
After considering the submissions of counsel and the relevant statutory provisions, the Tribunal stated that a taxpayer may file an objection and pursue reconciliation with the tax authority; file an objection and proceed to appeal before the Tribunal without waiting for the tax authority's response; or appeal directly to the Tribunal without first submitting an objection.
The Tribunal further held that paragraphs 2(1) and (2) of the Second Schedule to the Joint Revenue Board of Nigeria (Establishment) Act, 2025, are not inconsistent with Section 41(1) and (2) of the Nigeria Tax Administration Act, 2025.
Consequently, the Panel held that Divine Wisdom Institute and Pastor Edwin had duly exercised their right of appeal by approaching the Tribunal directly to challenge the February 2026 tax assessment without first filing an objection with the Edo State Internal Revenue Service.
The Tribunal accordingly struck out the Service's preliminary objection, thereby allowing the appeal to proceed for determination on its merits.
The Panel, which was chaired by Hon. Anselm Ungwugwaye Unimna, comprised Hon. Osariuyimen, Hon. Prof. Eiya, Hon. Aborisade, Esq., and Hon. Adewale as members.
Visit the judgment portal for full details